Knowledge

Nichia's Statement on EPO Judgment

May 12, 2022 Leave a message

On May 10, Everlight Electronics issued a press release stating that it had recently received a judgment from the Board of Appeal for Europe Patent Office, which agreed with Everlight’s appeal request for the invalidation of Nichia’s patent, and decided that Nichia’s patent was invalid. All claims of European patent EP2197053 are invalid.


In response to the recent decision of the European Patent Office and the press release issued by Everlight Electronics on May 10, Nichia today (12) issued the latest statement, the details are as follows:


1. The decision of the European Patent Office is only about the division sub-case in the YAG patent family. Although one sub-case EP2197053 (DE69740792) was withdrawn, the other sub-case EP2276080 (DE69740795) was corrected in the first instance procedure After the restriction, its effectiveness has been affirmed.


2. The validity and execution of the parent patent case of Nichia YAG, namely EP936682 (DE69702929), has not been affected in any way.


3. The validity of the parent patent of Nichia YAG has also been fully confirmed in two different invalidation procedures (case numbers: X ZR 96/14 and 2 Ni 55/16 (EP)).


4. In several infringement lawsuits based on the patent of Nichia YAG's parent case, the German court has determined that the defendant has infringed the YAG parent's patent, including the relevant judgment of Everlight and its German subsidiary WOFI's infringement. The final decision was made, and Nichia is currently pursuing the judgment against Everlight and WOFI to seek compensation for damages.


5. The cases mentioned in Everlight's press release, except for the European cases, are all old cases in the past, and are not the content of this decision. We hereby declare.


In order to maintain fair business practices, Nichia is committed to protecting its patents and other intellectual property rights, and will take appropriate and necessary measures against any infringer in any country.


Send Inquiry